Finding and hiring the right waitstaff is crucial for the success of any restaurant in Canada. An outstanding front-of-house team can set the tone, represent your brand, and directly impact the overall customer experience. However, identifying candidates with the ideal mix of skills and qualities can be challenging. This comprehensive guide will explore 10 essential qualities to look for when hiring waitstaff to help streamline your restaurant’s recruitment process.
Table of Contents
1. A Warm, Welcoming Attitude
Having a friendly, positive attitude is arguably the most important quality in a great server. Guests want to feel welcomed and appreciated from the moment they walk through the door. A server’s warm demeanor, genuine smile, and ability to make guests feel comfortable can significantly influence their dining experience.
When evaluating candidates, pay attention to their:
- Body language and eye contact during the interview
- Tone of voice and overall approachability
- Ability to engage in pleasant, natural conversation
A server’s attitude sets the tone for the entire dining experience, so prioritize candidates who exude warmth and positivity.

2. Great Waiters Are Also Great Communicators
Clear and effective communication is vital in the fast-paced restaurant environment. Servers must be able to:
- Accurately relay orders to the kitchen staff
- Clearly explain menu items and specials to guests
- Ask clarifying questions to ensure orders are correct
- Listen actively to guests’ requests and dietary needs
During the interview process, assess candidates’ verbal communication skills and their ability to listen attentively. Role-playing exercises can be helpful in evaluating these critical skills.

3. Why Emotional Intelligence Matters for Servers
Working in the service industry can be stressful, with servers frequently facing challenging situations and demanding guests. Patience and emotional intelligence are crucial for maintaining professionalism and providing excellent service, even in difficult circumstances.
Emotionally intelligent servers:
- Remain calm and level-headed under pressure
- Have empathy and can read social cues
- Manage their own emotions effectively
- Know how to diffuse tense situations with tact
Look for candidates who demonstrate self-awareness, emotional control, and the ability to handle criticism or complaints gracefully.

4. Top Servers Have Eyes in the Back of Their Heads
Attentiveness and keen observation skills are hallmarks of exceptional servers. The best servers can:
- Anticipate guests’ needs before they ask
- Notice small details, like when a water glass needs refilling
- Remember guests’ preferences or dietary restrictions
During working interviews or role-playing exercises, observe how well candidates pick up on subtle cues and respond accordingly.

5. The Importance of Waitstaff Who Work as a Team
Providing seamless service requires teamwork and collaboration among the entire waitstaff. Servers must be able to:
- Communicate effectively with other staff members
- Jump in to assist colleagues during busy periods
- Prioritize the overall guest experience over individual tasks
Look for candidates who exhibit a team-player mentality and can work well with others under pressure. Behavioral-based interview questions can help identify those with strong collaboration skills.

6. A Knowledgeable Server is Invaluable
In-depth knowledge of the menu, ingredients, and food preparation methods is invaluable for servers. Knowledgeable servers can:
- Confidently explain dishes and make recommendations
- Suggest food and beverage pairings
- Answer guests’ questions about ingredients or dietary restrictions
While menu knowledge can be taught through training, look for candidates who demonstrate a willingness to learn and a genuine interest in the culinary aspects of the job.

7. Hiring Waiters with Energy and Endurance
Working as a server is physically demanding, with long hours spent on one’s feet and intense periods of high-volume service. Stamina and a hard-working, energetic attitude are essential qualities to seek in candidates.
During interviews, assess candidates’:
- Physical ability to handle the job’s demands
- Enthusiasm and high-energy levels
- Willingness to go the extra mile for great service
Consider role-playing exercises or working interviews to gauge their endurance and hustle in a realistic setting.

8. Why Accuracy is Critical for Servers
Attention to detail and accuracy are paramount in the server role. Even small mistakes, like:
- Entering orders incorrectly
- Miscalculating bills or providing incorrect change
- Forgetting to communicate dietary restrictions
can negatively impact operations and guest satisfaction. Evaluate candidates’ attention to detail through exercises like reciting orders back or handling mock transactions.

9. Don’t Overlook Grooming When Interviewing Waitstaff
A server’s appearance and professionalism directly reflect your restaurant’s brand and image. Well-groomed servers who exhibit:
- Neat, clean attire appropriate for the role
- Polished, professional demeanor and body language
- Good hygiene practices
create a positive first impression for guests. Observe candidates closely from the moment they arrive for the interview.

10. Valuing Reliable Servers with Flex Schedules
In the restaurant industry, staffing needs can vary widely depending on shifts and peak periods. Reliable servers who are:
- Available to work a flexible schedule
- Consistently punctual and committed to their shifts
- Respectful about providing advance notice for time off
are invaluable assets. Thoroughly check references and work history to assess candidates’ dependability.

Talent Employment Inc – Let a Staffing Pro Handle the Vetting Process
While assessing candidates for all these essential qualities can be time-consuming, partnering with a respected hospitality staffing agency like Talent Employment Inc. can streamline the process. As Canada’s premier waitstaff staffing provider, Talent Employment Inc. has a rigorous screening process that evaluates candidates based on the exact qualities covered here.
Their comprehensive vetting includes assessing:
- Friendly, positive attitude and emotional intelligence
- Communication and teamwork abilities
- Menu knowledge and service skills
- Physical stamina and commitment to excellence
- Grooming standards and professional demeanor
- Reliability and schedule flexibility
By leveraging Talent Employment Inc.’s deep talent pool of pre-qualified, highly trained waitstaff, restaurants can feel confident they are accessing top-notch candidates perfectly suited for their needs.
Conclusion
Hiring exceptional waitstaff who embody the 10 qualities outlined above requires effort, but the payoff in outstanding service and enhanced guest experiences makes it well worth the investment. Don’t settle when building your front-of-house team – be selective and bring on servers who will represent your restaurant brand with poise, professionalism, and a true passion for hospitality.
Ready to start your search for Canada’s top waitstaff talent? Implement these criteria into your interview process today, or partner with the staffing experts at Talent Employment Inc. to gain access to a pool of pre-vetted, highly qualified candidates. With the right waitstaff in place, you’ll be setting your restaurant up for service excellence and success.
How does Talent Employment help to reduce hiring risks for businesses?
By staying up-to-date with current laws and regulations, Talent ensures compliance and minimizes risks related to bad hires and misclassification, providing fully secure staffing solutions.
What is the process Talent Employment follows to streamline hiring?
Talent simplifies the hiring process by managing sourcing, screening, interviewing, and onboarding, allowing businesses to focus on retaining top talent efficiently.
Why should a company partner with Talent Employment during busy periods?
Talent can quickly scale up hiring efforts during peak seasons, ensuring businesses have the necessary staff to meet increased demand without delays.
What are the benefits of different hiring models available through Talent?
Talent offers models like direct-hire, temp-to-perm, and probationary engagements, allowing businesses to assess a candidate’s fit before making a long-term commitment.
How much time can businesses save by using Talent Employment for hiring?
Talent’s efficient hiring process can save businesses significant time, allowing managers to focus on other critical responsibilities rather than spending hours on recruitment.
What hidden costs should businesses consider when hiring staff?
Beyond hourly wages, businesses should account for statutory expenses, overhead costs, benefits, training, and risks associated with turnover and theft.
How does Talent Employment ensure cost-effectiveness for businesses?
By providing skilled staff at competitive rates, Talent can help businesses save an average of $80 per day per employee compared to traditional hiring methods.
What makes Talent Employment a preferred choice for over 100 companies?
Many companies choose Talent for their flexibility in staffing needs, from casual to full-time roles, and their proven success rate in providing qualified candidates.
How can businesses get started with Talent Employment for their staffing needs?
Interested businesses can reach out directly to Talent to discuss tailored staffing solutions that meet their specific requirements and increase overall efficiency.